The man of steel (Gary Steel, that is) has been thinking about that Dotcom chap, and specifically, his album.
THEREโS A NOBLE tradition amongst serious exponents of electronic music craft thatโs particularly common amongst techno and house producers. These are dance music genres in which authentic craftspeople admire anonymity. They know that at its best, dance music is a level playing field: the dance floor is a place for people to shake their asses without having to worship the Godlike edifice of rock star-like celebrity. But of course, the more popular they get, the harder it is to shed a skin, and to simply be the sum total of the sounds on a disc. Some producers change their monikers with abandon, so it becomes a full-time job for fans to keep up, and exposes those fans as hopeless nerds. After all, they should really be chasing great sounds, not a brand. Other artist/DJs release 12-inch singles in limited white label editions with no name at all or, as in the case of the critically acclaimed dubstep producer Burial, keep their identity hidden. [Well, he managed that for seven years, but has recently blown his cover.]
On the other hand, thereโs no credibility in a dance music artist who exploits his music as part of a brand-building exercise, and thatโs my first big issue with that big man, Kim Dotcom, and his Good Times album.
For any New Zealander or resident who has kept up with news stories in the past couple of years, Kim Dotcomโs presence on the local scene, for better or worse, is huge. [Excuse the pun]. Had the FBI-engineered raid on his mansion never happened, itโs my guess that Dotcom would still have become a larger-than-life figure [excuse me again] on our tiny stage. Letโs not retread old details, but clearly, the controversy over the raid and the subsequent shutdown of Dotcomโs file-sharing business, the legal complexities, the business with our prime minister and John Banks and on and on, have all kept the Dotcom name in headlines.
And thatโs the problem in attempting to assess Dotcomโs album, which he has apparently pieced together in fits and starts during the troubles of the past couple of years.
I contemplated the possibility of hypnotism so my head would be devoid of any memory of Dotcom, and I could assess Good Times with none of the obvious baggage. But that would be a lot of trouble all in aid of what really is a lousy record.
In truth, I donโt know what I think of Dotcom and his various pursuits. On the one hand, it seems to me that his file-sharing site was only doing what many other file-sharing sites do, acting as conduits between sender and recipient in much the same way as snail mail or email. It seems to me that seemingly above-board websites like YouTube are brazenly above the law by allowing anyone to put anything online for anyone to watch or listen to, and only pulling it down when a copy-write owner complains. Compared to that, any supposed indiscretions of Dotcomโs Megaupload site, now closed, seem trifling. And it feels to me like the old guard in Hollywood have chosen a soft target to test their legal weaponry on, in the hope that he will be an example that scares off others, or perhaps sets a precedent, resulting in file-sharing sites dropping like a house of cards.
On the other hand, Dotcomโs tendency to throw money around in a fashion well documented through the 20th century by various nouveau riche comes across as garish and more than a little bit dull. Itโs that mindless hedonism thatโs about as subtle as a flying mallet and slimes its way through Good Times, one of the most excruciating albums to have troubled my CD player, and already a candidate for Worst NZ Album By A Rich Bastard In 2014, aka, an album that tastes like fart de foie gras.
Okay, let me be fair: there are a couple of good things about Good Times. One is the sound quality, which is decent. A lot of contemporary dance pop is compressed to buggery, but this isnโt. Thereโs a good amount of tightly controlled bass weight and the synth sounds, which dominate the mix, are nicely insectoid as they buzz from speaker to speaker.
Another good thing are the guests: people like Laughton Kora and Tiki Taane and Printz Board (Black Eyed Peas) who manage to ever so slightly elevate this sorry endeavour with whatever musical personality they possess. I said slightly.
And itโs not enough. Good Times is an aesthetic travesty, and at times itโs so bad that it made me shudder with a kind of cultural cringe reserved only for portly German narcissists who have the audacity to think that their business savvy extends to musical talent. Which brings me to this: just exactly what does Dotcom do on Good Times, anyway? Theoretically, he produced the album, at Neil Finnโs Roundhead studios, but did he play any hand in making the sounds found on the record itself? We may never know, or care to know. Certainly, itโs stacked with collaborators, and the only identifiable Dotcom moments are those excruciating Teutonic-tinged raps, genius lines like โSleep all day/Party all night/Have what you want/Whenever you likeโ (โGood Lifeโ). Shades of the Roastbusters?
While that song clearly maps out Dotcomโs superficial worldview, and the whole endeavour just goes to reinforce the manโs inflated [ha!] sense of self, itโs inevitably the horrible Euro-house flavours that kill the project stone cold dead. As early as the second song, the title track, the rhythm gets stuck in a kind of goosestep thatโs anathema to a country versed in the blissed out rhythms of Bob Marley and the dub skank of Fat Freddyโs Drop.
At times, itโs hard to imagine that Dotcom comes from a country famed for the pioneering work of electronic legends, Kraftwerk, whose ironic, darkly humorous and carefully layered work has endured, and influenced generations of the better techno heads. For a few euphoric seconds, the song โGood Timesโ even sounded a bit Kraftwerkian, but soon I was laughing at him, not with him, as he intoned: โHands in the air/Hands everywhere!โ in a leering rap that conjured up the ghost of none other than that entertainingly gauche Wellington electronic band, The Body Electric (remember โPulsingโ?) He does it again on โParty Electricityโ: โYou and me/We are wild/We are freeโ, and then: โWild, free, and sexy!โ You can almost hear him sweat. And then on โWunderbarโ, the killer line is, you guessed it: โOoh-la-la/You and me are/Wunderbar.โ
Then thereโs โKeeps Getting Betterโ (I only wish it would), on which vocalist Ilati comes on like a naughty teen wishing she was really Miley Cyrus, not propping up some rich blokeโs vanity project; and โTake Me Awayโ, possibly a true sentiment sung by Dotcomโs wife Mona.
Sadly, the project does guests like Kora and Taane no favours, either. โChange Your Lifeโ has the former trying his soul emoting to clichรฉd jackhammer beats and house clichรฉs, while on โLittle Bit Of Meโ, the latter allows his own brand to be submerged in a long drop reserved for arenas full of dumb shits waving their stumpy hands in the air.
Itโs possible that some of the above lyrics are sung with tongue in cheek. After all, Kim Dotcom has shown himself in interviews to be an articulate, and one suspects, thoughtful bloke. But none of that really matters, because in its totality, Good Times is such an affront to good taste that it should probably be extradited and classified and buried in the FBI files, even if the man himself is allowed to stay in NZ.
The reason Good Times pisses me off isnโt that I have any kind of beef with Dotcom. Itโs simply because itโs a waste of space in a crowded market, a rich manโs vanity project that proves nothing, is nothing except some noise to fill the terrifying void.
The real shame about Kim Dotcomโs album is that he could have invested the money it cost in the work of a genuine artist. But philanthropy doesnโt seem to be part of Dotcomโs mindset, just the pursuit of hedonistic pleasure. Pleasure without consequences. At the very least thatโs a shame; at the worst, something to be concerned about. GARY STEEL
Dot Dunger
Latest from Music
Who you jiving with that cosmic debris? Zappa’s Apostrophe (โ) at 50
Frank Zappaโs most popular album gets a chunky six-disc elaboration. GARY STEEL wonders whether it warrants the attention.
World’s Worst Records – Alison Gold’s Chinese Food
Our expert on the worst of the worst, the honourable MATT KELLY, gets stuck into a very dubious release that verges on culturally insensitive.
Moon Unit Zappaโs memoir: a ripping rock and roll read
The original valley girlโs memoir is an acutely observed and at times shocking tell-all about growing up in the dysfunctional family of a 1970s
World’s Worst Records – Dizzee Rascal’s The Fifth
Dizzee Rascal has made some acclaimed albums but The Fifth isn't one of them, writes MATT KELLY, who rues just how low the rapper
Shriekback: Making the brain dance
Way back in 1986 GARY STEEL chatted with Shriekback main man Barry Andrews prior to the groupโs NZ tour. Here's that interview.